SA国际传媒

SA国际传媒

Calif. street medicine program reflects on 4 years of service

An expansion of Medi-Cal funding has helped Clinica Sierra Vista deliver medical care to the homeless population

ClinicaSierraVista.jpg

Clinica Sierra Vista/Facebook

By John Donegan
The Bakersfield Californian

BAKERSFIELD, Calif. 鈥 As they slowly back onto the parking lot, you can hear the groans in the axles of Dr. Matthew Beare鈥檚 Honda Element. Years of climbing onto sidewalks, off-roading along riverbeds and combing underpasses have taken their toll.

But it鈥檚 part of the philosophy that Beare, a physician at Clinica Sierra Vista, has adopted to bring on-the-spot medical care to homeless people in Bakersfield, at no cost to the patient.

鈥淚nstead of asking patients to step out of their world and into ours, we step out of our comfort of our world and into theirs,鈥 Beare said.

He leads a six-person street medicine team that has since 2019 brought direct care to the 100 or so patients living along the Kern River bed. Every Thursday, after a supply stop at the county shelter, the crew rides to the riverside.

Street medicine crews see an average of 12 to 15 patients every Thursday, though Beare said that can jump to 30 on a busy day. Treatment includes almost everything you would see in a clinic 鈥 HIV, high blood pressure, diabetes 鈥 as well as wound care, particularly incisions and draining abscesses, and medication provided on the spot. Previously reliant on grants, Beare said the program is now billed through Medi-Cal, which makes it 鈥渟elf-sufficient.鈥

This morning, with the gates locked, the crew switched back and entered through the north side of the river, along a route they call Tammy鈥檚 Pass.

It鈥檚 near the Rosedale Inn, which sits in the evening shadow of the 24th Street overpass that crosses Golden State Highway. A turn onto an access road nearby takes the two vehicles onto an undulating dirt path with puddles from the recent tropical storm.

On either side is a field, charred black and barren from a recent fire, and the Kern River, swollen from recent rains and a record snowpack from the Sierra Nevada.

Tammy鈥檚 Pass

The first camp they spot explains the pass鈥檚 name. Tammy鈥檚 camp, positioned at the trailhead, consists of a reclining chair, a shelf and random furniture, all of which were covered with plastic-wrapped goods and a tarp.

Several hundred feet away, Beare points to a spot where he and his team came upon a woman being eaten alive by a pack of pit bulls. 鈥淭hat was a terrifying moment,鈥 he recalled. They had to carry the woman, her extremities ripped apart, with a tarp to an ambulance by the entrance.

Forming a canopy over the camp are two overgrown fig trees that form a cove over a camping chair. With Tammy still asleep in her tent, the crew continues along the dirt clearing past the bridge.

About a dozen people, and another dozen dogs 鈥 some leashed, some not 鈥 are waiting. Many of their health problems stem from the elbows or knees down 鈥 swollen tissue, bumps or dog bites that slowly worsen due to infection.

鈥淲e used to have to drive along the river and stop at each encampment,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淏ut now, we鈥檝e been coming out for so long that the patients congregate. They know where we鈥檙e going to be.鈥

Staff members make their rounds, handing out lunch, harm reduction kits, Narcan and clean needles. Coffee is self-served at a table set up by Kern Medical Supply. One team member takes blood pressure readings, while another 鈥 a medical student 鈥 bandages an open wound on a man鈥檚 foot.

Beare rotates from patient to patient, prescribing medicine and performing checkups. By this point, he鈥檚 acknowledged by most on a first-name basis and can recognize his patients from a distance.

One woman, Christine, showed some scratches on her arm, complaining of an itch. In the two years she鈥檚 been in Kern, Christine has relished the street team鈥檚 Thursday visits.

鈥淚 really like it. I think it鈥檚 awesome that they do this,鈥 she said. 鈥淲here I used to live before, in Phoenix, they didn鈥檛 have other people doing this.鈥

Medi-Cal, reimagined

Like many of the state鈥檚 homeless, Christine has Medi-Cal. But without transportation, she can鈥檛 get to a clinic for exams.

Beare explains that when they started this program, the teams used to have to go from site to site, asking to provide care to people.

Encumbered by higher rates of addiction, mental health disorders and illness, homeless individuals are among the state鈥檚 neediest patients.

While 60% of the state鈥檚 homeless, according to the California Health Care Foundation, are registered through Medi-Cal, only a third, according to a 2021 analysis by the California Legislature, have ever seen a primary care provider.

One of the few ways they can efficiently administer psychoactive medicine is through a recently adopted long-acting injectable. Beyond that, little can be offered in the way of psychiatry. When they first started, the team brought along specialists. They quickly realized it didn鈥檛 work.

鈥淲e try to see as many people as we can in a day,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淪o our interactions might be a few minutes, and while they鈥檙e meaningful and heartfelt interactions, they鈥檙e still pretty rapid. And a behavioral health intervention could be talking for an hour just to get a baseline.鈥

This population, unsheltered yet insured, must go without unless they can connect with one of Kern鈥檚 teams. This drives up the number of visits to emergency rooms.

A big change, Beare said, has been funding from the new California Advancing and Innovating Medi-Cal, or CalAIM program, an expansion of Medi-Cal funding that, since June, has made the team self-sufficient. Previously, the clinic paid out of pocket or relied on grants to help fund its efforts, often resulting in supply shortages.

鈥淚t gives us a degree of sustainability,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 the single biggest game changer you have seen and will continue to see as street medicine teams.鈥

Signs of those are apparent in California and across the nation. According to the CHCF, only 24 teams existed as of 2022.

鈥淚 just talked to someone and they said it鈥檚 closer to 49 teams in California, which is crazy,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淚 remember when there were only 200 teams in the world 鈥 like in Calcutta, in London, everywhere. And now there鈥檚 49 in California.鈥

Nationwide, street medicine teams are active in more than 60 American cities.

Beare believes teams like his will reduce emergency room visits and readmissions that bog the state鈥檚 Medi-Cal budget. According to the California Department of Health Care Services, more than half of the state鈥檚 $133 billion Medi-Cal budget is reserved for the top 5% of users.

鈥淚t also builds a rapport between the medical community and people experiencing homelessness,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 undoing a lot of damage done over the years.鈥

The next generation of medicine

It has also attracted the next generation of medical students who want to shed the formalities of a clinic setting.

鈥淭his is what I鈥檝e wanted medicine to be,鈥 said Shahab Alnagar, a fourth-year student at California Health Sciences University in Fresno, who shadowed Beare for the first time Thursday. 鈥淣ot appointment-based, you just walk up and take care of it on the spot.鈥

Yet as his team treats those wounds, new ones are continually opened.

The intersection of code and committee

Christine complained of harassment by local code enforcement, which is charged by the city to clear street encampments deemed a public nuisance. It鈥檚 an issue every five days, she said, with little room for negotiation.

鈥淭hey won鈥檛 talk to us, just tell us we have to go to court and that we have to talk to Flood (Ministries),鈥 Christine said. 鈥淏ut it鈥檚 not right away that Flood can get you out of here ... you have to wait years or months in order to get into housing. But that鈥檚 what they throw at us 鈥 talk to Flood, talk to Flood.鈥

Since each of the four shelters in Kern are regularly at or near capacity, Christine and others say they rarely have a choice of where they can stay. Bakersfield averages a 1% vacancy rate for affordable rentals, leaving housing options like downtrodden motels, which are arguably more dangerous than being outside.

And at an Aug. 22 city Housing and Homelessness Committee, Bakersfield Assistant to the City Manager Anthony Valdez reported that 71 individuals, on average, are turned away each week due to capacity limits at the Brundage Lane Navigation Center.

Over the years, Beare said, he and his team have increasingly been at odds with code enforcement.

鈥淓ncampments get moved a lot,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淭hese camps would otherwise probably stay stable, but the city moves them a lot. And what鈥檚 disheartening for us to witness, is they will upend and bulldoze a camp when it鈥檚 110 degrees outside 鈥 I鈥檝e seen it happen, multiple times.鈥

While he doesn鈥檛 want to demonize code enforcement personnel, it鈥檚 hard to watch 鈥渁 city government directly putting people at risk.鈥

鈥淚t鈥檇 be different if they said, 鈥榃e found you an apartment, we want to help take you over there, let鈥檚 go right now,鈥 but that鈥檚 not what happens,鈥 Beare said. 鈥淭hey put up a sign that says you have three days to get out of here ... we have different criteria for success.鈥

Phil Burns, the director of Bakersfield鈥檚 Building Division, which oversees code enforcement, said that among the four shelters in Kern, there鈥檚 always a bed available.

鈥淚 think there鈥檚 a misconception that these shelters are always full, 24/7. That鈥檚 actually not what practically happens,鈥 Burns said. 鈥淓very day you have a certain amount of people in the shelter that leave the shelter, get placed in housing 鈥 so there鈥檚 beds that become available.鈥

His department is tasked with dealing with the 979 calls to service complaints made to code enforcement along the Kern River alone between Aug. 1, 2022, and Aug. 14, 2023.

When Flood Ministries, which is contracted with code enforcement to monitor shelter availability, goes out there and makes contact, they鈥檙e not just referring people to the BLNC, but also to the other shelters in the area 鈥 M Street Navigation Center, The Open Door Network and The Mission at Kern County.

Yet in the aforementioned meeting, it was stated that 197 people refused shelter service in July, while the BLNC alone turned away an average of 65 individuals each week of that month. And the city does not monitor the vacancy rates of the three other shelters.

鈥淲e only track our shelter,鈥 Burns said.

Additionally, The Mission at Kern County is first-come, first-served. And the M Street shelter was closed to new clients last week after a COVID-19 outbreak.

鈥淭here鈥檚 things that may have some short-term impacts on availability, but in a general sense, we have way more individuals that refuse than ones that want to go to shelters,鈥 Burns said.

Burns added that BLNC reserves some shelter beds for 鈥渟ervice-resistant鈥 homeless people who change their minds.

There is also no policy in place, according to Burns, that says code enforcement will not remove an encampment in the event of extreme heat or cold weather. He did add that in times of inclement weather, like rain, they鈥檙e generally not going out.

鈥淏ut in the cold or the heat, we鈥檙e going to be out there 鈥 no different than any other day,鈥 Burns said.

Since the city does not track shelter capacity at other sites, it cannot say for certain whether encampments are razed only when a shelter bed is guaranteed to be available.

鈥淚n our point of view, housing is available to that person,鈥 Burns said. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 why we contract with Flood, to monitor that very issue.鈥

City of Bakersfield spokesman Joe Conroy said it鈥檚 not so much the intention to simply remove people from their encampments, but to get them to services.

鈥淚t makes most sense in inclement weather, whether it鈥檚 cold or hot, to get somebody into a shelter rather than being out in those elements,鈥 Conroy said. 鈥淚鈥檓 racking my brain trying to think of a situation where it would make more sense to leave them in those elements than try to get them service.鈥

In the event that BLNC, for example, does not 鈥渉ave the processing power to get them in that day,鈥 Burns said they will usually give that person another day at their encampment.

When encampments are razed, medications, documents, identification 鈥 things people need to access housing 鈥 are often buried or spilled into the river, Beare said.

Where the faded vinyl meets the stars

On the way out, they visited Tammy, who stood outside her tent, chatting with a man while another woman sat in the driver鈥檚 seat of a truck next to them.

鈥淎bout 4 o鈥檆lock I can come over here because by then we鈥檙e in the shade,鈥 she said. 鈥淎nd then I can sit in my chair.鈥

Since Beare and some of the others will be gone next week, the people here along the riverbed will be on their own.

After a year at this site, Tammy said code enforcement doesn鈥檛 bother her anymore. She spends her day waiting for visits, by friends or Beare.

On an average summer day, inside the cove with the buzz of cutter bees, she stretches out in her chair, which is patterned like the American flag, her head resting where the faded vinyl meets the stars.

(c)2023 The Bakersfield Californian (Bakersfield, Calif.)
Visit The Bakersfield Californian (Bakersfield, Calif.) at
Distributed by