By Wayne Parry
Associated Press
TRENTON, N.J. 鈥� New Jersey and the nation were not prepared when the COVID-19 pandemic hit, and the state 鈥渞emains underprepared for the next emergency,鈥� according to an independent report examining New Jersey鈥檚 response to the pandemic that sickened nearly 3 million people statewide and killed over 33,000.
The report released Monday faults planning, communication and decision-making before and during the pandemic, which broke out in early 2020.
Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy called the pandemic 鈥渢he greatest crisis our state has ever faced.鈥�
He promised an outside review of his administration鈥檚 response to the outbreak in its early days. The $9 million publicly funded report was done by the law firm of Montgomery McCracken Walker & Rhoads LLP and Boston Consulting Group. It was led by Paul Zoubek, a former assistant state attorney general.
鈥淚 know New Jersey will be better off because of this review, and my administration looks forward to working with the Legislature on its recommendations,鈥� Murphy said.
State Republicans have been sharply critical of Murphy鈥檚 performance during the pandemic, including mask mandates and shutdowns, but had not publicly reacted to the release of the report as of early Monday afternoon.
The report was blunt in listing failures leading up to the pandemic, as well as during it.
鈥淲e collectively failed as a nation and as a state to be adequately prepared,鈥� Zoubek wrote. 鈥淎t the state level, heroic actions were taken to respond in good faith to the crisis. Despite the lessons of the last four years, New Jersey remains underprepared for the next emergency.鈥�
The report also noted things New Jersey did well during the pandemic, including making 鈥渟ignificant systemic improvements.鈥�
鈥淭he state, to its credit, took bold and early steps designed to substantially reduce the number of people infected: shut-downs, quarantines, mask requirements, and social distancing were all implemented and resulted in dramatic improvements in health outcomes over the course of the pandemic. By the Delta and Omicron wave, New Jersey became one of the states with the lowest death rates,鈥� the report read.
It also said the state鈥檚 campaign to vaccinate residents and convince those hesitant to receive the shots helped New Jersey combat the spread of the virus.
鈥淏ut no level of effort could overcome an inadequate healthcare infrastructure and scarcity of basic medical supplies,鈥� the report read. 鈥淣either the state nor the federal government had clear, executable plans in place to respond to and manage such limited resources in an uncertain and rapidly evolving environment.鈥�
In a typical example, the report noted that in 2015 鈥� five years before the pandemic 鈥� the state health department created a 鈥減andemic influenza plan鈥� that the report said 鈥渨as extremely accurate in predicting what would eventually happen during the COVID-19 pandemic.鈥�
But the existence of that plan was not widely known within senior state leadership when COVID-19 hit, the report said, adding that several people in state government it interviewed said 鈥渟ome other agency鈥� ought to have an emergency preparedness manager for such instances.
鈥淚n fact, that position exists (and is staffed) in the other agency, but the people we spoke with were unaware of that fact,鈥� the report said.
The report also found that communal care facilities, including those caring for veterans were particularly vulnerable to the spread of the virus due in part to 鈥渨holly inadequate infection controls.鈥�
The report accepted previously issued criticism by the U.S. Department of Justice and the State Commission of Investigation finding 鈥渂road failures in leadership and management,鈥� including a 鈥渟ystemic inability to implement clinical care policy, poor communication between management and staff, and a failure to ensure basic staff competency (that) let the virus spread virtually unchecked throughout the facilities.鈥�
The report recommended updating and 鈥渟tress-testing鈥� existing emergency response plans, conducting training and practice exercises across the state for a wider range of emergencies, not just pandemics.